Cubs Playoff Roster
By Todd Johnson
Yesterday, I talked about the dilemma for the backup catcher spot. Today, it’s all about the bullpen. Or, as Joe Maddon now refers to them, bullpen men. The Cubs are likely to take eight of them east to Miami. Seven of those have been pretty set in stone since the beginning of camp in Brandon Morrow, Steve Cishek, Carl Edwards, Jr., Pedro Strop, Brian Duensing, Mike Montgomery, and Justin Wilson.
With just five days left until opening day, the Cubs have kept two spots open on their 40 man roster. One is likely for catcher Chris Jimenez and the other might be for one of the players they could be taking for the bullpen.
Lefty pitcher Randy Rosario has some MLB experience and is on 40 man, but I don’t think he wowed anybody this spring. As a result, he was sent down yesterday to trim the roster to 34. But pitchers Anthony Bass, Kyle Ryan, and Justin Hancock are still alive and all put together good springs.
Former starter Eddie Butler more than likely looks to have one spot locked up as he is out of options. Another spot could be open as Pedro Strop is not quite ready to return and could begin the year on the DL.
Just yesterday, reliever Justin Hancock pitched two scoreless innings to close out a game, even though it was against mostly minor league players. When spring training began, I didn’t think that Hancock stood much of a chance of making it through spring training, let alone this long. His ability to throw mid to upper 90s heat and to locate that heat made him an extremely viable candidate to make the team. According to Patrick Mooney of The Athletic, Joe Maddon said the following about Hancock’s arsenal: “He’s got a lightning bolt for an arm” and “He’s got A-lister stuff.” A pitcher is not going to get a much better rec than that. Hancock would need to be added to the 40 man if he did.
When Theo talked about adding strike throwers, he wasn’t kidding. Anthony Bass fit that bill this spring along with Kyle Ryan. Ryan did not have a good 2017. However, he was pretty good before that in Detroit. Being a lefty gives Ryan a distinct advantage over the other two. The 6’5” 26-year-old is an intriguing option who put up a 3.07 ERA in 56 games in 2016. But will Joe Maddon want to go with four left-handers in the bullpen?
Ryan pitched just 8 innings so far while Bass only got in 5.2. Those totals don’t seem enough to judge an extra reliever/bullpen man.
Part of me also wonders how much the Cubs will be looking at the waiver wire here the next few days to see if there’s a player with substantial talent that gets cut right before the season starts.
Another part of me says the Cubs are going to go with the more experienced player. In that case Ryan has the most experience and has actually had some success at the major-league level. On the other hand, Bass had the best spring, but is the oldest player at 30. As for Hancock, I think he has the most talent. And to be honest, talent usually wins out.
In the end, though, the bullpen on March 24 is not going to matter that much in the big scheme of things. I look more towards how the bullpen develops over the course of the summer and the names that are going to be there in October.
At some point, Dillon Maples will enter the discussion later this year along with my guy, Dakota Mekkes. A lot can happen between now and August 31, the day playoff rosters are due. The Cubs have a lot of time to sort things out for October. For now, though, they will have to make a decision just about who begins the season on the 25-man roster.
By Todd Johnson
Right now I feel pretty good about 2/5 of the rotation. Kyle Hendricks and Jose Quintana are pitching very well at this point in the season. When it comes to Lester and Arrieta, I’m not quite as confident. Can they turn around? Yes, but the question should be, will they? I was hoping that Jen-Ho Tseng and Rob Zastryzny would each get a start this weekend against Cincinnati to rest Lester while also allowing Arrieta the time to make one more start, even if abbreviated. Tseng is out after pitching 3 innings last night but there is hope that Zastryzny could start or even piggyback a start the next three days.
It is pretty much a given that the Nationals are going to trot out Max Scherzer and Stephen Strasburg in the first two games of the NLDS. If the Cubs can steal one of those two in Washington, I like the Cubs chances to win the series. Having to face either one of those arms a second time would be extremely hard to defeat. To win, the Cubs are going to have to beat one of them.
When trying to find a weakness of the Nationals, it is not that hard. They currently rank seventh in batting. However, against left-handers, they rank 24th. Against right-handed pitchers, they rank third in all of major-league baseball. A strange part of me says that maybe Montgomery should get a start and that maybe Justin Wilson could make the roster just for this series. But I’m not too comfortable in having the latter happen although the former doesn’t bother me much.
As it stands right now, the Cubs will have four days off next week before the series begins. This should allow them to lineup the rotation anyway they see fit. If the Cubs want to counter Scherzer and Strasburg with Quintana and Lester, I would be OK with that. Heck, you could even put Hendricks in at the #2 slot and I would be OK again. That would allow Arrieta and Lester to pitch at home. If Jake is not 100% when the playoffs begin, then Lackey seems to do very well at home or you could even throw Montgomery. I am hoping that Lester and Arrieta don’t pitch until they are absolutely needed. This would give them the time to properly recoup.
With the way Quintana is pitching, I really hope that he is the difference in this series. Over his last 33.2 innings, he’s struck out 40 with a 2.14 ERA and only has walked 4 batters in that span.
Hendricks has been outstanding lately, too. In September, he’s tallied 31.1 IP with 29 Ks against a 2.01 ERA and 5 walks. Before his hamstring, Arrieta had ERAs of 2.25 in July and 1.21 in August.
The pitching could be there for the Cubs to get back to the NLCS for the third straight year. It should be very interesting to see how it all will line up.
By Todd Johnson
It has been quite the run. In the past three years, the Cubs have won 290+ games. In the divisional era (since 1969), this is the second time the Cubs have won back-to-back division titles (2007-2008). It is their third playoff appearance in a row. And, this team is built for many more seasons of postseason play.
For me, it was pretty sweet that the clincher came in St. Louis. It had been a tough year to be a Cubs fan as the team did not live up to expectations in the first half. The Cubs were two games under .500 and 5.5 GB Milwaukee. How they have played since the All-Star break has been very gratifying and exciting to watch.
It is now time to turn attention to who should be the 25 players on the playoff roster. I think 22 players are pretty much a given. So, it all comes down to adding three players. What position player will get the nod and what 2 relief pitchers will make the squad?
Sure Shots to Make the 25
Position players: Wilson, Avila, Rizzo, Baez, Zobrist, Russell, Bryant, Schwarber, Jay, Almora, Happ, Heyward
Pitchers: Lester, Hendricks, Quintana, Arietta, Davis, Strop, Rondon, Montgomery, Edwards, Duensing
Making the Case: Position Players
Who is out? – Rivera, Davis, Freeman, Martin
Outside Looking In: La Stella, Caratini, and Rivera
With the core of 12, I’m not sure whether manager Joe Maddon would rather carry an extra bat or an extra catcher. If it’s a bat, Tommy let Stella would be the best answer. If it’s a catcher, then he goes with Rene Rivera. I tend to think that Maddon will lean catcher but ultimately La Stella’s patient approach will work better in the playoffs. Caratini would be a long shot and would be my personal second choice as he can switch hit. If the Cubs go with La Stella, and an emergency catcher is needed, then Joe has to go with Schwarber. The most logical bat is Tommy La Stella.
Making the Case: Pitchers
Who Is Out: Wilson, Tseng, Zastryzny, Maples, Pena
I do think Dillon Maples making the roster would be amazing. While his stuff might be ready, he is not. I do hope he gets a lot of work the next five days and gets to experience the postseason even if he is not on the roster. As for Justin Wilson, I don’t think he is consistent enough to get on the roster. He was pulled in the middle of a batter Monday night.
— CSN Chicago (@CSNChicago) September 28, 2017
That leaves Grimm, Lackey, and Uehara.
This is a tough call. Part of me says that maybe the Cubs should bring Lackey on as a long man rather than pick either of the other two. At times, Uehara has looked good this year and at other times, he’s been very hittable. Grimm, meanwhile, has looked like a train wreck most of the second-half. It doesn’t look like this will be a win-win situation.
I am not sure how this will all shake out over the next week. While I feel pretty good about the La Stella pick, I also know that Rivera is also a good choice based on Maddon’s preferences. As for the pitchers to be on the roster, Maddon could pick any two of them. I do not feel good about those selections at all.
We shall see. Part of me hopes for a surprising pick….or two.
Here is the schedule so far. Times to be released later.
Game 1: 10/6 at WSH
Game 2: 10/7 at WSH
Game 3: 10/9 at CHI
Game 4: 10/10 at CHI
Game 5: 10/12 at WSH
By Todd Johnson
With the arrival or Brian Duensing in Chicago, the Cubs’ bullpen now contains two actual left-handed relievers and Koji Uehara, whose stats versus lefties make him appear to be left-handed, even though he is a righty. With Duensing at 34 and Uehara at 42, the thought of injury is not far away from my mind. In fact, Duensing just came off the DL. Do the Cubs just ride with these two all year? To me, it doesn’t inspire a lot of confidence.
Based on the roster makeup this year, I thought the Cubs would go out and get another lefty reliever at some point during this summer. I think that’s a good way to look at it. In the meantime, the organization would try and develop one, just in case of an injury. Maybe Theo and Jed thought that one of the pitchers they signed at the winter relief pitcher extravaganza would pull through. Maybe they thought they would give their signings and prospects a few months to earn that coveted spot or two.
Here is what the Cubs have at each level when it comes to left-handed relievers.
Iowa: Jack Leathersich, David Rollins, Rob Zastryzny
Rollins is standing head and shoulders above the other two right now, who have been knocked around pretty good in just 10 days. Rollins has yet to allow run in three appearances. When it comes to Zastryzny, he is having trouble locating. Last year was such a big year for him as he changed his grip on his cutter which revolutionized his arsenal. Hopefully, he can turn it around and make it back to Chicago before the All-Star break. I thought he was excellent last year and was surprised he did not make the club.
Tennessee: Gerardo Concepcion
Concepcion made it all the way to Chicago and had a cuppa coffee in the show. He didn’t stay there, but he did have the step to get there. This year it appears he’s going to have to go through two levels to get back to Chicago. He needs to get his fastball back up to 93 and to continue to be aggressive. So far at Tennessee, it is not going well. He’s made for appearances with a 5.40 ERA.
Myrtle Beach: Jordan Minch, Tommy Thorpe, John Williamson
I really like to watch Jordan Minch pitch. He is deadly against left-handers and if it were not for an injury last year, he would more than likely be in Tennessee this year. So far he’s pitched 4.1 innings and he’s only allowed two hits. Thorpe and Williamson are also loogy specialist but not as dominant as Minch has been the last year.
South Bend: Marc Huberman, Jose Paulino, Wyatt Short
Although Paulino has yet to debut, ’ I think he has the most potential as a reliever from the left side in the Cubs’ system. He throws 93 to 95 with a wicked awesome slider/curve. He dominated in the first half of Eugene’s’ dominating run to a championship before coming to South Bend. He was OK as a starter at South Bend but has been moved to the bullpen this past off-season. He stayed for a little extra time and extended spring training and I cannot wait to see what he does in 2 to 3 inning stints this summer. Short and Huberman are also very dominant. Both have been excellent so far this season. Combined, the trio makes up the best collection of left-handed bullpen arms in the system.
Injured: Manny Parra
I have not heard of a timetable for his return as he is recovering from Tommy John surgery.
Right now, it would be hard to make a judgment just based on three or four appearances. I think Rollins and Zastryzny would be the clear two front runners for the summer. While Rollins is pitching well, I do not think he is the dominant picture of the Cubs are looking for to use in the playoffs. However, he is good enough to help them get there if needed. The same is true for Zastryzny.
As a result, I think the Cubs will be looking to acquire a lefty sometime by the end of July. Next year, however, we could be looking at Paulino, Minch, Short, and maybe even Huberman, as possible options for a left-handed reliever(s).
Ian Happ (jaw on floor).
— Len Kasper (@LenKasper) March 13, 2017
It’s not uncommon for a Cubs prospect to come up to spring training and do well. Last year was Jeimer Candelario. This year it is Ian Happ. Happ has been crushing the ball to the tune of a batting average over .400 with some serious power and the ability to play second base and the outfield.
Happ is currently is one of the 40 players still on the Cubs spring training roster. If he were to make the club, a 40 man roster spot would have to be made available. I don’t see that happening. At all. And like Candelario from last year, Happ will eventually be set back down to the minor leagues. His season will most likely begin in AA Tennessee where he has some unfinished business.
On the other hand, I think Ian Happ could return to Chicago to make another roster, the one for October.
A month ago, no one would’ve asked the question about whether Ian Happ could break camp with the big league club. While Happ is an incredible talent, he’s also is streaky one.
After an amazing June and early July last summer, he was promoted from Myrtle Beach to Tennessee. In that span between the two clubs, he hit over .600 with an OPS well over 1.000.
While Happ has only been a professional for year and a half, he does have many attributes the Cubs are looking for, especially for October. One is he is a switch hitter who can play all three outfield spots and second base. He’s an exceptional athlete who is probably going to hit better the higher he progresses through the system. The reason I say that is that the pitchers will be around the plate more. It’s hard to hit well A ball when some pitchers are just randomly wild.
I have been critical of Happ’s streakiness at times and I think it was warranted. I do think he needs to be a more consistent player and I think this is the year that will happen. Being a professional is not easy. Considering Happ’s first year, he had to deal with the death of his father. Last year saw him taking on his first year of full season baseball. That’s an adjustment for anyone. Now that he’s got that under his belt, I think he will be physically and mentally stronger for it.
Why I like him so much is I think he can hit for average and for power and get on base at a high clip. At every level he has shown a propensity to take his walks despite a fluctuating batting average. His power, like any power hitter will come and go. I think the ability to see balls and strikes is something that never changes.
While I don’t think he’s ready for the grind of a major league season just yet, nor would he see the playing time he probably needed, I do like him for October much more than La Stella and/or Szczur. There’s just something about the way he hits the ball and hits it hard. Watching his hands go through the zone is perfection. It is the sweetest part of his swing.
While his name has been bandied about in trade talk for the past six months, I don’t think the Cubs are quite ready to send him off after the spring he’s had. In fact, I think they would rather see him in Chicago, especially in October.
The big league club clinched home field advantage Friday night for the National League Playoffs! The Cubs won their day game against the Cardinals, and then later that night, Pittsburgh defeated Washington. As a result of the Cubs owning the tiebreaker, the Cubs clinched a day early. Now, 100 wins would be nice to conclude the regular season.
It also appears that with a week to go, Chris Coghlan has moved ahead of Tommy La Stella for one of the final playoff roster spots. Albert Almora should make it as well, although the race between Almora and Matt Szczur is a lot closer.
In a small ceremony held before the Cubs game on Friday, Trevor Clifton and Eloy Jimenez were presented with their awards as Minor League Pitcher and Player of the Year. The awards were announced the week before and congratulations are still in order.
In fall instructs, Tom Hatch made his pro debut pitching BP and impressed Cubs Den’s John Arguello. The Cubs 3rd round pick from 2016 did not pitch in the Cubs system this summer after throwing 130 IP in college ball this spring.
When it comes to the Cubs Convention, I haven’t decided if I am going. Unfortunately for me, it begins on a school improvement day. I don’t know if I will be able to get out of that commitment. I really enjoy going to the Saturday and Sunday sessions the following days.
I have a new Top 21 List up.
There are several changes throughout the list. It keeps getting younger and younger. And those younger players keep moving higher and higher. After graduating a lot of high profile bats, the list now has a majority of pitchers for the first time ever. Moving up the list quickly in the past two months are Zach Hedges and Trevor Clifton. Dylan Cease is still entrenched in the top 3. I almost put him at #2.
And like previous lists, this one, too, will only be temporary. I could change it after fall instructs, but I would rather wait until early January. The main reason is I think the Cubs are going to move some top prospects to acquire a young, cost-controlled starting pitcher.
Come 2017, I think a lot of the International Free Agent Class of 2015-2016 will be knocking on the doors of the US to get in and play some rookie ball in Mesa, and/or short season ball in Eugene. There’s a lot of talent in that group led by Jonathan Sierra, Aramis Ademan, and Yonathan Perlaza.
Cards of the Year
The Pitching Urgency
A Year Without Schwarber
Top Cub Moments of 2016
*Thomas Hatch card made from a photo by John Arguello
I think we need to consider ourselves very, very lucky. The past two years have seen the greatest Cubs teams in my lifetime. The 2016 team has to be the greatest Cubs team I’ve ever seen. They just demolished the competition in April, May, and early June. After a little slump in late June to mid-July, the Cubs turned it back on after the All-Star Break. The Cubs have the pitching, the defense, the bullpen, and the hitting to get it done. All the parts are in place to win a World Series Championship.
Questions now turn to who is going to be on the 25 man roster for the National League Divisional Series.
Here is who I see as givens:
C – Miguel Montero, David Ross, Willson Contreras
IF- Anthony Rizzo, Javy Baez, Ben Zobrist, Addison Russell, and Kris Bryant
OF – Jorge Soler, Jason Heyward. Dexter Fowler
SP – Jake Arrieta, Jon Lester, Kyle Hendricks, and John Lackey
RP – Aroldis Chapman, Hector Rondon, Pedro Strop, Justin Grimm, CJ Edwards, Travis Wood, and Mike Montgomery
That’s 22 spots.
3 are left. Who is on the outside looking in?
Albert Almora, Matt Szczur, Chris Coghlan, and Tommy La Stella are hitters who could take up 2 of the 3 spots. Then, Jason Hammel, Joe Smith, or Trevor Cahill could take up another spot. On the other hand, the Cubs could just carry 11 pitchers for a five-game series. I tend to think they might be leaning that way. Which means there will be an odd man out.
Who do I think should make the NLDS roster?
1. Albert Almora – For me, he has to be in left field come the eighth or ninth inning. He doesn’t even have to have an at-bat. Almora’s inclusion would sandwich Dexter Fowler between two gold glove caliber outfielders.
2. Matt Szczur – I bet I hemmed and hawed about 20 times between Szczur and Coghlan. Although the Cubs do not have a player who has elite speed, Szczur is the closest thing to it. He provides a valuable right-handed bench with the potential for power. He also can play all three positions in the OF if need be. Let’s hope that the Cubs just use him to pinch run, a role for which he is ideally suited.
3. Tommy La Stella – I really don’t want to see Tommy La Stella play second or third base at all. When you have Javy and Zobrist doing what they do, his defense is not required. On the other hand, La Stella does have a pretty good hit tool from the left side and he tends to hit good pitching well.
I think Coghlan was very close to making it in my mind. He could still make it on the NLCS roster as could Jason Hammel or Trevor Cahill. I actually think Hammel does become that long man in the NLCS.
With three weeks to go, it should be interesting to watch these final three spots play out. I honestly don’t think that Theo, Jed, and Joe are totally sold on the final roster. Sure, they probably have a pretty good idea. I think Almora is given, but when it comes to that last spot, I think Coghlan, La Stella, and Szczur are still going to be duking it out for the next three weeks.